Complete coverage
Roof Cargo Carriers
Roof boxes and cargo bags ranked on capacity, aerodynamics, mounting, and weather protection.
Roof cargo comes in two philosophies. Hard boxes, from Thule, Yakima, INNO, and SportRack, lock, shrug off weather completely, and slice through air with tolerable noise. Soft bags, from Rightline Gear, FIVKLEMNZ, MeeFar, and Amazon Basics, cost a fraction as much, fold away in a closet, and ask you to trust zippers, seams, and straps against the weather. Neither is wrong; your trip frequency and storage space decide.
The ten carriers below are all sold on Amazon and span roughly 15 to 21 cubic feet. We weighted fit honesty, because a box is only useful if it clears your hatch and fits your crossbar spread, alongside real weather behavior and mounting hardware quality.
Every guide on roof cargo carriers
13 guides
Best of
The Best Roof Cargo Carriers (2027)
The best roof cargo carriers for 2027, ranked on capacity, weather protection, mounting hardware, aerodynamics, and storage practicality.
Read guide
For family road trips
The Best Roof Cargo for Family Road Trips (2027)
The best roof cargo carriers for family road trips in 2027: maximum usable volume, easy loading, and honest weather protection.
Read guide
For ski trips
The Best Roof Cargo for Ski Trips (2027)
The best roof cargo carriers for ski trips in 2027: internal length for skis, cold-weather hardware, and lockable protection.
Read guide
For small cars
The Best Roof Cargo for Small Cars (2027)
The best roof cargo carriers for small cars in 2027: compact boxes and bags sized for short roofs and modest load limits.
Read guide
Review
Thule Motion XT XL Review (2027)
Thule Motion XT XL · An 18-cubic-foot premium box with dual-side opening and SlideLock security.
Read guide
Review
Rightline Gear Sport 3 Review (2027)
Rightline Gear Sport 3 Car Top Carrier Bag · An 18-cubic-foot soft carrier from Rightline's rack-mounted Sport line.
Read guide
Review
SportRack Vista XL Review (2027)
SportRack Vista XL Roof Box · An 18-cubic-foot rear-opening box at a mid-market price.
Read guide
Review
Thule Force XT Rooftop Cargo Box, X-Large Review (2027)
Thule Force XT Rooftop Cargo Box, X-Large · Thule's X-Large box: the longest shell in this guide at 82.75 in, in matte black ABS.
Read guide
Review
Rightline Gear Sport Jr Car Top Carrier (10 cu ft) Review (2027)
Rightline Gear Sport Jr Car Top Carrier (10 cu ft) · A 10 cu ft waterproof soft carrier sized for compact cars, rack or no rack.
Read guide
Head to head
Thule Motion XT XL vs Yakima SkyBox 16 (2027)
Head-to-head: Thule Motion XT XL versus Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite on capacity, finish, hardware, and highway manners.
Read guide
Head to head
Rightline Gear Sport 3 vs MeeFar Roof Bag (2027)
Head-to-head: Rightline Gear Sport 3 versus MeeFar Roof Rack Cargo Bag on weather protection, mounting, sizes, and value.
Read guide
Buying guide
Roof Cargo Carriers Buying Guide (2027)
How to choose a roof cargo carrier in 2027: box versus bag, roof load limits, hatch clearance, crossbar fit, and waterproofing methods.
Read guide
Fix it
Roof Cargo Noise, Leaks, and Shifting? Fixes (2027)
Fix roof carrier wind noise, strap buzz, water leaks, and load shifting with packing, mounting, and hardware adjustments.
Read guide