Head to head
Evenflo Eat & Grow 4-in-1 vs Chicco Polly (2027)
Head-to-head: Evenflo Eat & Grow 4-in-1 versus Chicco Polly on modes, folding, padding, and price.
Evenflo Eat & Grow 4-in-1 Convertible High Chair
The budget 4-in-1 that converts from high chair to a big-kid table and chair.
- Age / weight: 6 months to 50 lb (22.6 kg)
- Harness: 5-point, removable in later modes
Chicco Polly Highchair
A padded folding high chair with 7 heights and a slim fold.
- Weight limit: Up to 40 lb
- Height / recline: 7 heights, 3 reclines
Our recommendation
Buy the Eat & Grow if budget and conversion modes lead your decision. Buy the Polly if you need padding, recline, height range, and a fold that frees the kitchen between meals.
Cleaning
The Eat & Grow relies on a machine-washable pad and a removable tray. The Polly's padded seat is comfortable but its seams and straps demand more work after every meal.
Adjustability and fold
The Polly offers 7 heights and 3 reclines and folds compactly. The Eat & Grow instead converts through four modes, from high chair to a table and chair set, without folding.
Limits and price
The Eat & Grow reaches 50 lb against the Polly's 40 lb and costs far less; the Polly premium buys padding, recline, and the fold.
Choose Evenflo Eat & Grow 4-in-1 Convertible High Chair if…
- Budget is decisive
- You want modes that grow to a table and chair
- You prefer a machine-washable pad
Choose Chicco Polly Highchair if…
- You need the chair to fold away
- You want recline and height adjustment
- Padding matters for a smaller baby
Questions, answered
Which lasts longer?
By weight limit, the Eat & Grow (50 lb) outlasts the Polly (40 lb), and its final mode is a table and chair set rather than a high chair.
Which is safer?
Both meet ASTM F404 with a 5-point harness and crotch post. The Polly adds recline positions for younger babies; the Eat & Grow relies on its four fixed modes.
Can the trays go in the dishwasher?
The Polly tray liner and the Eat & Grow removable tray are sized for sinks first; check your dishwasher lower rack before relying on it.